I think I suggested too many fish. Also some non-fish.
Origami Fish
“How does it breathe?”
Tubafish
“A starfish with its neck stuck in a tuba. Ow.”
Huge Goldfish
“Who knew goldfish could be as large as sharks?”
Duck
“A cool pet duck to buy with sea dollars. I don’t think it’s a fish though.”
Santa Claws
“It turns out Santa was a crab the whole time.”
Sea Bunny
“A cute slug that looks like a bunny. Do not touch.”
Easter Sea Bunny
“A sea bunny that gives you eggs.”
Pumpkin Fish
“A jack-o-lantern with a fish-shaped carving on it that can swim, apparently.”
Knight Fish
“I used to swim like you, until I took an arrow to the fin.”
Ghost Fish
“This fish likes floating in air, because ghosts don’t need water.”
Cake Fish
“This fish was shoved in a cake, which is why it just looks like a floating cake. It’s okay.”
Sea Sponge
“Great for cleaning counters, and making fast food.”
King Crab
“He is the king of crabs, and has a cool robe and crown.”
Giant Crab
“This crab might try to pinch you. Attack its weak points for massive damage.”
Frog
“it’s not a fish, but you can buy it with sea dollars.”
Toad
“This isn’t a mushroom, sorry.”
Loot Box
“This box contains a random piece of garbage. Have fun!”
Sunken Submarine
“How did you fish this up?”
Lucky Clover
“Someone dropped their lucky clover in the water, but it’s yours now. (doesn’t increase odds for jackpot or cosmic catsacks)”
Penny
“Finally, something that costs 1 unit.”
Broken Wheel of Money
“A Wheel of Money someone threw in the water. It’s rusty and broken now, but you can still put it in your house.”